On this page 7 sections
Official government statistics (MHCLG PS2, calendar year 2025) put England's planning approval rate at 87.0% across 300,645 decisions in 310 local planning authorities — yet search for one council online and websites can disagree by more than 30 percentage points. In a check of roughly 15 UK planning-data and home-improvement sites on 14 November 2026, published "approval rates" for Croydon ranged from 54.1% to 87.3%, even though Croydon's official 2025 MHCLG PS2 rate is 75.2%.
Most of that gap comes from three methodological choices websites rarely disclose beside the headline percentage: data source, date range, and what counts as a decision.
For every English council's standardised official figures, see PlanWatch's planning approval rates by council hub and our Planning Postcode Lottery 2026 study.
The Croydon 33-point spread: one borough, nine different rates
On 14 November 2026, search snippets across roughly 15 planning websites quoted Croydon's approval rate as 54.1%, 69%, 75.2%, 78%, 79.99%, 80.5%, 81.0%, 86.6%, and 87.3%.
Now look inside Croydon's single official 2025 MHCLG PS2 return (code E09000008, 1 January to 31 December 2025):
- All decisions combined: 1,190 granted of 1,582 decisions = 75.2% (rank #299 of 310 English authorities)
- Other applications (predominantly householder): 809 granted of 953 = 84.9%
- Major developments: 17 granted of 23 = 73.9%
- Minor developments (e.g. 1–9 homes, small commercial): 364 granted of 606 = 60.1%
Even within one official dataset, Croydon spans 60.1% to 84.9% depending on project scale. Once sites mix different years, partial portal scrapes, withdrawals, or non-planning certificates, the spread hits 33 points.
Six reasons websites publish conflicting approval rates
1. Official MHCLG PS2 returns vs scraped council registers
Every quarter, all 310 English local planning authorities report standardised decision totals to MHCLG on the PS2 statistical return (300,645 decisions in 2025). Every council follows the same definitions, making PS2 the only consistent national baseline.
Scraped portal datasets collect individual rows across hundreds of council websites, introducing three common distortions:
- Partial authority coverage: Some published multi-year archives cover around 180 of England's 310 authorities, omitting major councils such as Wiltshire (3,734 PS2 decisions in 2025) and Bristol (2,112 decisions), while holding under 50 historical rows for large authorities like Buckinghamshire (4,436 decisions in 2025) or Shropshire (2,039).
- Generic portal statuses: Many portals stop updating statuses beyond
"Decided"once a case closes. In PlanWatch's October 2026 audit of 271,286 scraped register rows, 49,416 rows carried non-committal labels like"Decided"or"Decision Made"without stating pass or fail, and 47,247 rows were"Unknown". - Headline catalogue vs calculation sample: Some sites highlight tens of millions of UK records from wider catalogues in page headers while calculating their percentages from a much smaller mixed-route subset with an unknown collection date.
2. Status-text parsing bugs (missing refusals inflate rates)
UK councils have no shared wording for outcomes. PlanWatch's October 2026 outcome audit found 428 distinct status strings across 271,286 register rows — plus 842 distinct decision-text strings across 31,615 harvested decision pages.
When a parser misses a council's refusal wording, refusals drop out of the denominator and push approval rates artificially high:
- Luton: Luton's register prefixes refusals as
REF - Application Refused(67 rows in PlanWatch's audit) while using standard wording for approvals. Before PlanWatch patched its classifier in October 2026, those 67 refusals were missed, making Luton's scraped records read 100% approved against an official 2025 PS2 rate of 76.3% (550 of 721). Recognising the prefix brought Luton's scraped rate to 78% across 305 decisions. - Gravesham: Counting
Certificate Refused(18 rows) while excludingCertificate Granted(51 rows) dragged Gravesham's register rate down to 74.1%; classifying both sides consistently moved it to 78.4%, while core planning applications alone stayed at 73.7%.
3. What counts as a decision: withdrawals, certificates, and "not required" rows
Even on the exact same register export, inclusion rules swing rates dramatically:
- Withdrawn applications: Official PS2 calculates
granted ÷ (granted + refused)and excludes withdrawals. Including withdrawals in the denominator (granted ÷ all submitted) pulls rates down by 5 to 15 points in strict councils where officers steer weak applications toward withdrawal before refusal. - Lawful development certificates (LDCs), prior approvals, and conditions: Mixing LDCs, prior approvals, condition discharges, and non-material amendments into planning permission pulls rates up. In publicly documented mixed-route archives where the authoritative legal route is missing on 100% of rows, an "extension approval rate" blends full householder applications with permitted-development certificates.
- "Consent not required" and consultee replies: Portal rows such as
"Permitted Development","Prior Approval Not Required", conservation-area tree exemptions ("Tree Works - Auto Permit"), and"No Objection"responses to neighbouring councils are not planning permissions. PlanWatch's October 2026 classifier explicitly excludes 41 "consent not required" strings (1,177 rows) and 30 consultee-response strings (750 rows) from approval rates.
4. Date range: one recent year vs decades of legacy data
New Local Plans, Article 4 HMO directions, and housing-land-supply shifts can alter refusal rates within 18 months. A 12-month PS2 window (such as calendar year 2025) reflects current decisions, whereas multi-decade archives stretching back to the 1990s average superseded policy regimes — and publicly audited exports show over 16% of rows in some legacy archives carry no decision year at all.
5. Application scale and project type
Nationally in 2025 PS2 data, councils approved 89.1% of "other" (mainly householder) applications, 87.3% of major applications, and 82.0% of minor applications. By project type, PlanWatch's Planning Postcode Lottery 2026 analysis of 27,265 decided register cases found 93.9% approval for garage conversions and 90.6% for extensions, versus 75.9% for changes of use and 69.5% for 1–9 new homes. Comparing one site's householder rate against another's minor-development or all-submissions rate easily creates a 25-point gulf.
6. "Decided in time" vs real calendar waiting times
Official MHCLG PS2 reports 90.6% of English decisions made "in time" in 2025 — including 91.5% in Croydon, 94.5% in Cornwall and Wiltshire, and 97.5% in Luton. That counts any decision issued within an agreed written extension of time (EOT) or planning performance agreement (PPA): 650 of Croydon's 1,582 decisions (41.1%) and 2,095 of Wiltshire's 3,734 decisions (56.1%) involved one. Measuring raw calendar days from registration to decision across 9,409 Q1 2026 decisions, PlanWatch found only 43.8% landed within 8 weeks (median 59 days, with 20.5% taking over 13 weeks).
Method comparison table
| Method | Formula | Typical Bias | Coverage & Freshness | Best Used For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Official MHCLG PS2 (overall) | Granted ÷ (Granted + Refused) | Neutral, standardised baseline | All 310 English LPAs (307 ranked >= 50 decisions); quarterly | Fair council-to-council comparison |
| Official MHCLG PS2 (by scale) | Granted ÷ Decisions within Major, Minor, or Other | Neutral per band | All 310 English LPAs; quarterly | Separating householder ("Other") from 1–9 home ("Minor") odds |
| Strict scraped register (core planning) | Approved ÷ (Approved + Refused) on core planning only | Low when refusals & "Decided" gaps are audited | Varies by portal; excludes withdrawals & non-decisions | Project-type splits (extensions vs new homes) and real wait times |
| Mixed-route archive | Approved ÷ Decided across planning, LDC, prior approval, conditions | Upward (+3 to +12 points) | Uneven council depth; often multi-decade with undated rows | Rough historical volume only — not an official planning rate |
| All-submissions rate | Approved ÷ (Approved + Refused + Withdrawn) | Downward (−5 to −15 points) | Register-based; penalises pre-refusal withdrawals | Raw submit-to-grant attrition rather than refusal risk |
How to read official MHCLG PS2 tables yourself
You can verify any English council's official numbers directly from GOV.UK in five steps:
- Download the latest 4-quarter PS2 CSV from GOV.UK live tables on planning application statistics (the 7 April 2026 file covers 2025 Q1–Q4, matching PlanWatch's UK Planning Approval Rates 2026 report).
- Filter to your authority across all four quarters (for example,
Croydon, codeE09000008) and sum all four rows. - Calculate the overall rate:
Total granted ÷ Total decisions— for Croydon:1,190 ÷ 1,582 = 75.2%. - Match the scale column to your project:
- Householder extensions/alterations ("Other"): Croydon
809 ÷ 953 = 84.9%. - Small housing/commercial ("Minor"): Croydon
364 ÷ 606 = 60.1%. - Large schemes ("Major"): Croydon
17 ÷ 23 = 73.9%(note the small 23-case sample).
- Householder extensions/alterations ("Other"): Croydon
- Inspect extension-of-time reliance: Compare decisions with a performance agreement or extension of time (650 in Croydon) against total decisions (1,582) to see how much of the 91.5% "in time" figure depended on extended deadlines.
Five English councils side by side (official 2025 MHCLG PS2)
| Council (2025 PS2) | Total Decisions | Overall Rate | Major Rate | Minor Rate | Other / Householder | Official In-Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Croydon | 1,582 | 75.2% | 73.9% | 60.1% | 84.9% | 91.5% |
| Leeds | 3,649 | 83.4% | 90.6% | 83.0% | 83.3% | 90.3% |
| Bristol, City of | 2,112 | 86.0% | 92.5% | 78.0% | 89.7% | 87.4% |
| Cornwall | 4,956 | 92.6% | 87.9% | 87.5% | 97.0% | 94.5% |
| Wiltshire | 3,734 | 93.0% | 82.1% | 88.5% | 95.1% | 94.5% |
In Croydon, householder-dominated "other" applications sit 24.8 points higher than minor schemes (84.9% vs 60.1%). Quoting either band without clearly labelling it misleads readers right away.
Five questions to check any approval rate online
- Source: Official MHCLG PS2 statistics (or devolved equivalents), or a scraped register export?
- Date range: One recent 12-month window (e.g. 2025 Q1–Q4), or an undated multi-decade archive?
- Withdrawals: Excluded from the denominator (standard PS2), or counted as non-approvals?
- Routes included: Core planning applications only, or mixed with LDCs, prior approvals, and
"Not Required"notices? - Sample size: At least 50 annual decisions (the threshold behind PlanWatch's 307 ranked English authorities), or a handful of rows?
Check your council's official PS2 numbers on PlanWatch's planning approval rates directory or test your project with our free planning approval odds checker — no phone number required.
Official Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the official source for planning approval rates in England?
The official source is the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) quarterly PS2 district planning statistics. In calendar year 2025 (released 7 April 2026), England's 310 local planning authorities recorded 300,645 decisions: 261,678 granted and 38,967 refused, an overall approval rate of 87.0%.
Why can websites disagree by 30 percentage points for the same council?
Because sites measure different things. Differences in data source (official PS2 returns vs partial scraped registers), date range (one recent year vs decades of records), what counts in the denominator (withdrawn applications, lawful development certificates, prior approvals, or condition discharges), and application scale (householder vs minor vs major) routinely shift a headline rate by 10 to 33 points.
Do official MHCLG approval rates include withdrawn planning applications?
No. Official MHCLG PS2 approval rates divide decisions granted by total decisions made (granted plus refused). Withdrawn applications are excluded because the council never issued a decision. Websites that put withdrawals in the denominator show lower rates, especially in strict councils where officers advise applicants to withdraw weak schemes.
Why is a council's 'decided in time' rate higher than real waiting times?
Official MHCLG PS2 statistics count a decision as "in time" if it met an agreed written extension of time or planning performance agreement. In 2025, 90.6% of English decisions were officially in time, yet PlanWatch's sample of 9,409 Q1 2026 register decisions found only 43.8% were decided within 8 calendar weeks (median 59 days).
Does my project type change approval odds as much as my council?
Yes. In official 2025 PS2 data, Croydon approved 84.9% of "other" (mostly householder) applications but only 60.1% of minor applications such as 1-to-9-home schemes. Nationally, PlanWatch register data shows extensions approved 90.6% of the time against 69.5% for 1-to-9-home schemes.
How can I check my council's official approval rate myself?
Download the MHCLG PS2 open data table on GOV.UK (District planning application statistics, updated quarterly), filter to your local planning authority across four quarters, and divide Total Granted by Total Decisions — or view PlanWatch's official MHCLG table covering all 310 English authorities.
Disclaimer: PlanWatch provides general information about UK planning processes. This content is not legal advice. Planning law is complex and varies by local authority. Consult a qualified planning consultant or solicitor for advice specific to your situation.